Product · creative

Your best ad has a shelf life. It knows when it expires.

Creative fatigue is invisible in platform dashboards - CPA rises slowly, frequency creeps up, and by the time you notice you have spent a week of budget on an ad nobody is clicking. Anti-Agency Club watches for it and calls the refresh before the CPA proves it.

Run the free diagnostic Join the waitlist

Ad sets · creative health

Retarget-UK · 61 days Freq 4.2

Fatigued - refresh now

Prospecting · 24 days Freq 2.6

Slipping - queue a refresh

Lookbook video · 9 days Freq 1.4

Healthy - keep running

Concepts live 2 of 8

Diversity too low

FIG 1.1 - Creative health by ad set. Illustrative.

The creative picture

Caught late by CPA, or caught early.

Before · running on fumes

-CPA creeping up so slowly nobody flags it.

-Frequency past 4 with no alert anywhere.

-The same two concepts across eight ad sets.

-Refreshes postponed because they take effort.

-CTR looks fine while incremental revenue is zero.

After · refreshed on time

01Retarget-UK creative 61 days old, frequency 4.2 - refresh now.

02Only 2 concepts across 8 sets - ship a new variant this week.

03Lookbook video beats static 2.4x - shift production to video.

Fatigue flagged the week it starts, weighted by the revenue each ad set drives.

What it watches

What Anti-Agency Club watches.

Fatigue · frequency

How often they have seen it.

It tracks how many times your audience has seen each ad set and flags when frequency crosses the threshold where performance historically drops - measured, not guessed.

Frequency Per ad set Decay rate

Diversity · concentration

How many concepts are live.

It measures how many distinct creative concepts are running at once and flags when you are leaning on too few - the concentration risk that turns one tired ad into a bad week.

Diversity score Concentration risk Ship new

Revenue · not clicks

Whether it drove orders.

It measures whether the creative drove orders that actually showed up in revenue, not just CTR - an ad can look healthy on engagement and be driving nothing incremental.

Revenue-linked Not vanity CTR Refresh timing

Proof

"Our hero ad had quietly doubled in frequency. Flagged the week it started slipping - not a month after CPA climbed - we refreshed and performance held."

Creative strategist · illustrative, composited from client work

18 days

Average creative lifespan before fatigue begins. After that, every impression is less effective than the last. Illustrative, from client work.

FAQ

Questions.

It reads frequency, performance decay and creative metadata per ad set and checks each against real revenue. It measures whether the creative still drives orders, not just whether engagement looks tired.

No. Most tools stop at CTR and engagement. Anti-Agency Club follows through to whether the creative drove orders in Shopify or your CRM, so a high-CTR ad driving no incremental revenue gets flagged.

Yes. Creative sits alongside paid and search in one model, so a refresh can be ranked against a budget move on the same weekly plan.

Read-only access, encrypted in transit and at rest, never sold or used to train models. Revoke any connection in one click; data is deleted within 30 days.

We're pre-launch. Join the waitlist and you'll get priority access as we open up - first through the door, not the forty-first.

Find which creative is still earning its budget.

Run the free diagnostic to see your verdict, then join the waitlist for priority access when Anti-Agency Club opens up.

Run the free diagnostic Join the waitlist